Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real

A Review

My children are watching Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real, a docudrama on DVD from the Discovery Channel. It's hard not to laugh.

Well, no, it isn't.

It's impossible.

We'll just hit the major fantasies contained in this docudrama; the ones that leaped out at me. We'll look at ...

  • Animals over 500 lbs. don't fly
  • If dragons like those in the docudrama existed, then we'd have found their fossils
  • Hydrogen-assisted flight in a large animal is useless.
  • Four-legged creatures with wings—and thus 6 limbs—do not exist and have never existed

Understand that Discovery—I hear it was on TV on Animal Planet—is not claiming Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real is actually ... well ... "real." They are taking a legendary creature and suggesting how it might really have existed.

None of the discoveries described in the DVD are real.

Flying, 900-Pound Dragons

It is extremely unlikely that a 900-pound reptile could fly. It's unlikely enough to call it impossible.

The BBC did report on an extinct bird that weighed 70 lbs, which could glide. There's also a Scientific American article suggesting that some flying pterosaurs could have weighed up to 550 lbs., though the lower—and more common—estimate is 250 lbs.

Dragon painting by Paolo Uccello

Pterosaurs could fly. David Unwin of the University of Bristol and Natasha Bakhurina of the Russian Academy of Sciences report in a letter to the scientific journal, Nature:

It is now generally accepted that pterosaurs, Mesozoic reptiles, were true fliers, but the nature of their flight apparatus is still much disputed.

Kevin Padian is a paleontologist at U.C. Berkely, and he is the most cited scientist on the subject of pterosaurs. He says:

Pterosaurs were just the coolest things that were ever in the air ... And it terms of size, they pushed the envelope as far as it could go for a flying animal. (science.nationalgeographic.com)

Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real suggests these dragons would be 900 pounds. Animals over 500 lbs., and probably over 300 lbs., don't fly.

If Dragons Existed, We'd Have Found Their Fossils

If dragons—at least dragons like the ones in Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real—existed, we'd have found their fossils.

Think about it. The docudrama brings up pterosaurs and crocodiles. We have tons of fossils of both. No one speculates about whether they ever existed.

900-lb. winged, flying creatures that are not pterosaurs would have been found.

Hydrogen-Assisted Flight in Large Animals Is Useless

This was the biggest joke of all in Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real.

When I saw this, I laughed out loud, stopped the DVD, and explained to my children what I'm about to explain to you.

Hydrogen is buoyant in air because it is lighter than air in the same way that wood is buoyant in water because it's lighter than water. The difference between the weight of the air and the weight of the hydrogen is how much lift the hydrogen will provide.

According to a fact sheet from Spectrum Laboratories, hydrogen has a lifting power of .076 lbs. at 32o fahrenheit and average barometric pressure (760 mm). (That figure matches what I found at a Los Alamos National Lab page, but the Los Alamos page is down now.)

So let's assume this hypothetical dragon could make room inside itself for a 10'x8'x8' space, the size of a small bedroom. This is exaggerated by a lot, but let's give it the benefit of the doubt.

That's 640 cubic  feet. Hydrogen can lift .076 pounds per cubic foot. That totals 48.6 pounds ...

... if it could open up a bedroom-sized space inside itself.

Houston, we have a problem.

Worse, as the dragon got higher, the density of the atmosphere would decrease, so the lifting power of the hydrogen would decrease as well. Also, if you heat the temperature above freezing, the lifting power decreases as well because the air, which is lifting the hydrogen, grows less dense as it heats.

Nor does it do any good to compress more hydrogen inside the dragon. As you do so, the weight of the hydrogen simply increases, and thus its lifting power decreases, not increases. You will get the ultimate lifting power from a vacuum, so you'd want less hydrogen, not more.

Finally, think about the last tank of helium you bought ...

  • Did it float away?
  • Does the tank weigh anywhere near 900 lbs.? One person can carry it.
  • Did it float away as the tank emptied and lift increased?
  • When you picked it up, did you feel the buoyancy of the helium?

Of course, none of these things happen with helium tanks. They don't happen with dragons, either, despite what Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real suggests. Adding hydrogen, even at the highly exaggerated amount of 640 cubic feet, creates an 850-lb. lift problem rather than a 900-lb. one ... at best.

Four-Legged Dragons

No 6-limbed creature has ever been discovered.

Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real shows dragons like the statue in Ljubljana ...

Everything that has wings has only two feet. Yes, pterosaurs and bats sometimes go around on their two feet and their wings as well, making them somewhat quadrupedal, but none of them have or had 6 limbs.

This point doesn't make a bipedal—rather than quadripedal—flying dragon impossible (though the earlier points do), but I bring it up to point out that Discovery wasn't trying very hard to be scientific.

If Dragons Are Not Real, Why Not All The Legends

There's lots of explanations for this, though I'm not for writing off legends.

There's plenty of indication that the Loch Ness monster never existed. Yet there's been many sightings, and several purposeful hoaxes.

So there's a few drawings of dragons and some stories. The medieval drawings could have been the products of the stories. The stories could have been the product of imagination or of exaggeration of real animals. There are plenty of creatures in the sea big enough to be legitimately considered sea monsters. The stories of world travelers who saw things like a komodo dragons would have led to some pretty outrageous stories.

Is there a possible real basis for dragon legends, so that a large, fire-breathing reptile could exist?

It's hard to say anything's impossible, but the reptile from Dragons: A Fantasy Made Real has to be close.

Return to Mythical Creatures

Home | Contact Me